About Our Team
James (Jim) Williams
President
Jim is the President of Williams & Case Insurance Agency. The grandson of co-founder Gail W. Williams, Jim joined in 2000 before graduating from Mount Union College (now the University of Mount Union) in Alliance, OH. He lives with his wife, Marie, in Alliance.
Jim is licensed in the following states to provide the following coverage:
Ohio
- Individual – Resident – Major Lines
- Casualty
- Life
- Property
Pennsylvania
- Casualty and Allied Lines
- Property and Allied Lines
Indiana
- Property and Casualty
Florida
- Property and Casualty
Julie Anderson
Office Manager, Agent
Julie is our Office Manager and an Ohio-licensed insurance agent who joined us in 2018. She lives in Hanoverton with her husband, Tim, and their three kids, Danika, Tucker, and Fisher.
Julie is licensed in Ohio to provide the following coverage:
- Individual – Resident – Major Lines
- Casualty
- Property
Kylie McLean
Agent
Kylie is a licensed insurance agent who joined us in 2024. She is a graduate of The Ohio State University and enjoys showing cows in her free time.
Kylie is licensed in Ohio to provide the following coverage:
- Individual – Resident – Major Lines
- Casualty
- Property
Katie Shaffer
Agent
Katie is a licensed insurance agent who joined us at the end of 2022. She moved from Florida to Sebring with her husband, Joe, and her two sons, Allen and Shawn.
Katie is licensed in Ohio to provide the following coverage:
- Individual – Resident – Major Lines
- Casualty
- Property
Who We Serve
Williams & Case Insurance Agency provides targeted coverage to clients throughout Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania. Operating from our office in Sebring, OH, our independent agents serve individuals and businesses needing customized protection plans.
Our range of insurance plans includes coverage for:
- Homeowners and Families: We provide personalized property, auto, umbrella, and other personal insurance properties.
- Small Business Owners and Contractors: We write comprehensive coverage for offices, retail shops, construction sites, and independent contractors.
- Farms and Agricultural Operations: We design custom agricultural protection for livestock, crops, farming equipment, and farm liability.
- Manufacturers and Commercial Properties: We secure critical coverage for heavy equipment, business inventory, general liability, and employee protection.
- New Residents and Relocating Families: We help newcomers obtain local policies quickly and efficiently.
Since 1946, Williams & Case Insurance Agency has insured regional residents and organizations with policies designed to offer the best local coverage. Whether you’re buying a home in Sebring, managing a manufacturing facility in Canton, or operating a farm in Hanoverton, our licensed agents will deliver specific solutions to meet your exact needs.
Why Choose Williams & Case Insurance Agency?
Williams & Case Insurance Agency is an established independent insurance firm headquartered in Sebring, Ohio. Since 1946, we’ve protected individuals, businesses, and farms throughout Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania.
Clients select Williams & Case Insurance Agency for our distinct advantages, including:
- Independent Multi-Carrier Expertise: Williams & Case agents compare personal, commercial, and farm insurance options from top carriers to secure optimal coverage and competitive pricing.
- Tailored Insurance Solutions: The team customizes every policy to address your specific needs.
- Deep Local Roots: Operating directly from Sebring, we have deep knowledge of how to best serve the surrounding communities, including Alliance, Salem, Canton, Akron, and Youngstown.
- Third-Generation Leadership: President Jim Williams leads a licensed staff that brings decades of Ohio insurance experience to every consultation.
- Verified Industry Trust: Williams & Case maintains active memberships with Trusted Choice, Ohio Insurance Agents, and the Alliance Area Chamber of Commerce.